iPhone Update and Ringtones
Saturday, September 29th, 2007This weekend I updated my iPhone to the new version that includes the Wi-Fi music store. This is also the version that makes “bricks” out of “hacked iPhones,” whereby owners tried to leave AT&T.

My iPhone works well with the update. Among the things to notice (of course), is the iTunes Music Store, with its purple button hanging off alone there in the bottom row. The keyboard includes new foreign characters (such as the upside down question mark used in Spanish), and then there is the case of my ringtones.
My custom ringtones are listed, but they do not sound. They fire blanks. Not happy.
Apple is in the business of selling ringtones. Er, snippets of songs you already bought and want to cut-up into a less-than 30 second chunk and pay for again. I have no interest. None of the songs I’ve bought on iTunes are ringtone-capable. In fact, I made some of my own ringtones based on pieces of music I composed myself.
And they disabled these?
While they may feel they have the right to disable ringtones I made from CDs, to disable my own sounds/music seems rather presumptuous. Of course, I subscribe to the idea that these ringtones for $1 bit is obnoxious to start with.
The ringtones started a number of Apple complaints being posted online. I am finally feeling the complaint personally now.. that the iPhone is a tad “too closed” for my taste. While I honor Apple’s right to sell me music, and too ringtones, I don’t have to buy them. But come on, I can’t make my own? Isn’t Apple about creative content sharing? I write a GarageBand song? Why not on my iPhone?
I think ultimately the device that is open enough for people — for apps or ringtones of whatever else — will ultimately be the favored product. iPhone won’t have the interface/experience advantage forever…

